Blog Post
5 min read

Local Flavors of the Thousand Islands: Must-Try Restaurants

Published on
January 14, 2025
Share this post

The Thousand Islands region is a captivating blend of stunning landscapes and exhilarating activities, but it's equally an oasis for food enthusiasts. Nestled along the sparkling waters of Alexandria Bay, you'll discover a delightful array of charming eateries, lively pubs, and picturesque waterfront restaurants that offer a wide variety of the region's distinctive culinary offerings. Start your day with a delicious, hearty breakfast featuring locally sourced ingredients, savor the exquisite flavors of freshly caught seafood for lunch, and unwind in the evening with a perfectly crafted cocktail as the sun sets over the horizon. The local dining scene is a treasure trove of unforgettable experiences, each bite telling a story of the region's rich heritage. Here are some must-try culinary gems that will surely enhance your gastronomic adventure.

Waterfront Dining & Local Favorites

Riley's by the River

Hours: 8 AM – 8 PM

Location: 48 James St, Alexandria Bay

Perched high above the lively harbor, Riley's is a charming restaurant that serves a delightful array of classic American dishes. From the moment you step inside, the aroma of freshly made fluffy pancakes fills the air, enticing you to start your day on a delicious note. For lunch or dinner, savor their mouthwatering juicy burgers, expertly grilled to perfection and served with an assortment of toppings.

The ambiance at Riley's is not just warm and inviting; it's a sensory delight. Large windows frame the breathtaking views of the harbor, where boats gently bob in the water, and the sun casts a golden glow over the landscape. Whether you're enjoying a leisurely brunch or a sunset dinner, the stunning vistas enhance the flavors of your meal, creating an unforgettable Thousand Islands experience.

Dockside Pub

Hours: 11 AM – 10 PM

Location: 17 Market St, Alexandria Bay

Dockside Pub is a charming and inviting venue to relax and enjoy great food and drink. Renowned for its delicious charbroiled burgers, each bite is a flavorful experience, complemented by a wide selection of craft beers on tap that cater to every palate. The warm and welcoming atmosphere makes it an ideal gathering place for sports fans, with plenty of screens to catch the game and casual diners seeking comfort food favorites. Whether you're dropping by for a casual meal or celebrating with friends, Dockside Pub provides the perfect backdrop for a memorable outing.

Riverboat Bar

Hours: 4 PM – 10 PM

Location: 15 Church St, Alexandria Bay

Riverboat Bar boasts a charming atmosphere with a high, airy ambiance and a spacious covered patio, making it the perfect spot for a relaxed outing with friends. Guests can indulge in a delectable selection of bar bites and succulent wings while sipping refreshing cold beverages. The inviting setting encourages laughter and conversation, making it an ideal gathering place to unwind and enjoy good company.

Windows on the Bay

Hours: 7 AM – 12 AM

Location: 17 Holland St, Alexandria Bay

Perched gracefully along the riverbank with breathtaking views of the majestic Boldt Castle, this upscale seasonal restaurant serves as an idyllic setting for celebrating special occasions. Guests can savor a delectable array of traditional American cuisine, expertly prepared to delight the palate. As you dine, immerse yourself in the tranquil ambiance of the waterfront, where the gentle sounds of the river and the stunning scenery create an unforgettable experience.

Family-Friendly & Casual Comfort

Coleman's Dock of the Bay

Hours: 12 PM – 9 PM

Location: 2 James St, Alexandria Bay

Coleman's is a welcoming, family-friendly tavern delights diners with a diverse menu featuring mouthwatering barbecue, succulent fresh seafood, and satisfying hearty American fare. From the rich, smoky flavors of tender, fall-off-the-bone ribs to the golden, crispy perfection of fried fish, every dish is crafted to satisfy a wide range of cravings. Whether you're in the mood for classic comfort food or vibrant seafood dishes, Coleman's promises a delightful dining experience for everyone.

The River House

Location: 9 Market St, Alexandria Bay

Nestled along the water's edge, The River House is a bustling venue that radiates energy and warmth. With its inviting ambiance, it features an eclectic menu filled with delicious culinary creations that cater to all tastes. The delightful aroma of expertly crafted dishes fills the air, enticing both locals and visitors alike to return time and again. As the evening unfolds, the venue comes alive with vibrant live music, creating an exhilarating atmosphere perfect for dining, socializing, and making lasting memories.

Wolfe's Kountry Kottage

Hours: 7 AM – 2 PM

Location: 43641 NY-12, Alexandria Bay

Renowned for indulgent breakfast options until 2 PM, Wolfe's is a beloved dining spot that delights patrons with its daily specials and delectable homemade pies. Each pie is crafted with care, offering a taste of comfort that warms the heart. Whether you're in the mood for a classic breakfast or a sweet treat, Wolfe's ensures a satisfying experience with flavors that evoke nostalgia and joy.

The North Star Family Restaurant

Hours: 6:30 AM – 2 PM

Location: 114 Church St, Alexandria Bay

This inviting restaurant has a delightful all-day breakfast menu that caters to both early risers and late sleepers and an appealing selection of lunch and dinner options. Specializing in classic American cuisine, it boasts a wide variety of hearty omelets and other beloved favorites. To enhance your dining experience, a curated selection of craft beers and fine wines is available, perfectly complementing each meal.

Unique Local Gems

Riverwatch Dining

Hours: 4 PM – 9 PM

Location: 17 Holland St, Alexandria Bay

Riverwatch Dining is the perfect destination for families, featuring a delightful kids' menu that caters to young taste buds. The inviting outdoor seating area is pet-friendly, allowing you to bring your furry friends along, and offers stunning views of the riverfront, creating a relaxed and enjoyable atmosphere. Known for its extensive selection of fantastic cocktails, the restaurant effortlessly combines a laid-back vibe with mouthwatering food, making it an ideal spot for a casual meal by the water.

The Local Bakery & Diner

Hours: 7 AM – 7 PM

Location: 24 Church St, Alexandria Bay

This charming locally-owned bakery and diner is a delightful destination for food lovers, offering an enticing selection of freshly baked goods that fill the air with warm, comforting aromas. Their creative twists on classic dishes make each meal an extraordinary experience, whether you're stopping by for a hearty breakfast, a leisurely lunch, or a decadent sweet treat to take with you. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, it's the perfect spot to indulge in delicious flavors and unique culinary creations.

Savor the Thousand Islands

From the fluffy, golden pancakes that greet the day at sunrise to the refreshing cocktails that toast the evening, the dining scene in Alexandria Bay captures the enchanting essence of the Thousand Islands. Picture yourself seated at a sun-drenched table by the water's edge, where the gentle lapping of the waves provides the perfect soundtrack to a leisurely meal. Indulge in the day's catch, expertly prepared to highlight the freshest seafood from the surrounding waters. And don't miss the chance to treat yourself to a slice of homemade pie, where each bite bursts with rich flavors and memories of local baking traditions. In Alexandria Bay, every dish is a delicious narrative woven with the threads of local ingredients and heartfelt hospitality.

Plan Your Culinary Adventure

Elevate your experience at Swan Bay Resort & Marina by indulging in the vibrant culinary scene of Alexandria Bay. Discover a selection of must-visit restaurants that showcase the area's rich flavors and local ingredients. Each establishment offers a unique atmosphere, allowing you to savor everything from fresh seafood to homemade delicacies. Let the mouthwatering dishes become integral to your Thousand Islands adventure, turning every meal into a cherished memory. Start planning your trip today and immerse yourself in the delightful tastes of this stunning paradise!

Subscribe to newsletter

Subscribe to receive the latest blog posts to your inbox every week.

By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.